More on writing high-earning evergreen topic pages for news websites

I wanted to address some questions and reactions to my piece last week about optimizing news websites for maximum AdSense revenue.

The questions focused on my final recommendation: “Create sharply focused evergreen topic pages”

Since this is the most important of my recommendations, I felt it deserved some extra attention, especially since some folks appear to be having a tough time wrapping their heads around it. If you follow all the rest of my advice but fail to create evergreen topic pages on your website, you might notice an improvement in AdSense earnings, but you won’t earn lucrative CMPs without them.

From the comments last week, a question:

“What is a ‘sharply focused’ evergreen content page?”

And from my e-mail, another:

“I’m wondering: you mention ‘evergreening’ your site. But won’t ‘niche’ sites that are specific to a handful of closely related topics get the same result, but also be updatable with daily news without making google’s bots upset?”

One OJR reader offered an answer to the first:

“My guess it means a [frequently] updated page that contains content with a common theme. for example, only sport news”

Not quite. A true evergreen page won’t be updated frequently. Its content should be written in a way that makes it, well, evergreen – able to stand as factual information for a relevant audience for a long period of time.

The page does focus on a single theme. But neither a niche website nor a topic index on a general news website necessarily serves the function of an evergreen topic page. A optimized evergreen topic page ought to focus on a single element within a theme – not just sports, for example, but on soccer officiating in the World Cup.

I understand why this might be a tough concept for some news veterans. After all, what I’m asking you to create is in several ways the opposite of what we do on a daily basis writing for newspapers or broadcast reports. This is a different product for a news organization, but one much closely aligned with its core mission than fake front pages or coupon deals.

An evergreen page doesn’t lead with the latest increment of knowledge about a story. It won’t be superseded tomorrow by fresher information. Its content is driven by readers are searching for through Google and other search engines, and not by what sources deliver us through events, document data, news releases or tips.

These pages stand apart from daily news updates on a news website, though sharp journalists should take advantage to refer to them to help bring new readers “up to speed” on the background behind hot news topics.

Start here: Forget for a moment that you work as a journalist. Think of a place or topic that you don’t cover, but in which have some curiosity: A hobby, or a favorite vacation destination, for examples.

Imagine that you are sitting down at your computer, with Google or Bing on your Web browser. What will you type to find information about that hobby or destination? Jot down those words, phrases or questions.

Now imagine that you are an uniformed reader, doing the same about the beat or place that you cover. Remember, you’re an uninformed reader, who’s not been reading your coverage. Stay general.

Write down those words, phrases and questions. Those will be the topics of your evergreen content pages. On those pages, you’ll provide the answers to those questions, or the detail behind words and phrases, ideally in less than 1,000 words.

The title of the page should be enclosed in an H1 tag, and include the relevant word, phrase or question that you’re addressing on that page. You also should use that in the lead paragraph of the article and at least three other times in the piece.

You might think this a sop to a search engine robot. Actually, it’s a writing trick to keep you on topic. Sharp focus is essential, both for attracting traffic and targeted ads to the page, as well as fulfilling your readers’ information need.

Finally, these pages must be linked to from the front page of your website, and ideally from all relevant internal pages as well. Burying links to these pages inside individual daily news stories won’t expose them to enough readers to build any viral support for the pages. And if they’re not linked to from the front page of the site, search engines won’t consider them important anyway.

A right-side navigation rail provides a great place to spotlight topic pages such as this. In fact, a right-side rail topped by a medium rectangle ad provides also provides a great home for a lucrative ad position. (See my post last week for more on that topic.) Plus, it loads all pages of your news website with this core keywords and phrases that you’ve identified.

We first started using evergreen topic pages on OJR, with the “How-to Guides” you’ll still find linked from the right side of the page. (FYI: We introduced them back when OJR was an ad-supported website with a student writing staff. We no longer run ads nor employ students on the site.) I stumbled onto the value of evergreen content pages when I wrote my “statistics every writer should know” tutorial in 1996. I added AdSense ads to that site in 2003 and continue to earn several hundred dollars a month from those pages today.

How many of you would like to be earning several hundred bucks a month from something you wrote 14 years ago? My hand’s up. How about yours?

Now let’s multiply that income by all the writers covering all the beats maintained in a larger news organization. Sharply focused evergreen content pages can provide an additional income opportunity for news organizations of all sizes.

How to optimize your news website for better Google AdSense revenue

A hot topic of discussion during last month’s KDMC News Entrepreneur Boot Camp was online advertising networks, specifically Google’s AdSense program for publishers. More than one speaker cautioned the participants to not expect much from AdSense. At the camp and at other industry gatherings, I’ve heard many folks dismiss AdSense revenues as delivering CPMs “in the pennies.”

Yet I know, from personal experience and from speaking with other publishers in the program, that much higher returns are possible, including daily average CPMs in double digits – and yes, I mean dollars, not cents.

How can a news website publisher earn more money from AdSense? I suspect that because starting with the program is so easy – you can set it up with little or no thought at all – that many AdSense publishers give the program… little or no thought.

That’s a huge mistake. Everything that you do on your website – from design to reporting to community management to advertising – should be done with intent. Give any aspect of your publication little thought, and you should expect little in return from it.

If you’re going to put AdSense ads on your website, or banner ads of any type, you must do so thoughtfully, using sound optimization techniques. Based on my experience, here are my suggestions for AdSense publishers:

Choose the right ad units
You want to place ad units on your site that are used widely by advertisers. While AdSense uses industry-standard ad sizes, some sizes clearly are more popular among advertisers than others.

In addition, some ad sizes support graphic ads, including Flash, while others rarely attract image ads. You want as many advertisers competing for your ad space possible, so select ad sizes that support the entire range of ad formats.

In my experience, AdSense offers three ad formats that deliver high CPMs:

  • The 160×600 Wide Skyscraper
  • The 300×250 Medium Rectangle
  • The 728×90 Leaderboard

In addition, an AdSense Link Unit can deliver respectable CPMs, if placed in a logical navigation position on your site, such as at the bottom of an article, the top of the page, or after a navigation bar.

Opt into image ads
When AdSense first launched, its text ads stood out among the flood of bad image banners polluting the Internet at the time. Today, with so many publishers, from large newsrooms to part-time bloggers, deploying AdSense on their websites, well-produced Flash and Animated GIF ads are the ones that stand out and elicit clicks.

But you won’t attract those ads onto your site if you haven’t opted into images ads for your ad placements.

Simplify your page design
Most newspaper websites are laden with horribly complex page designs. Keep it simple, if you want your readers to see and click on your ads. A basic two- or three-column layout is all you need online for most text-driven context. Lose the layers, the floating cells and the carousels. Design your page layout around the positioning of those ad sizes I mentioned above and flow your articles and navigation simply around them.

Here’s my rule: Complex page design = lousy ad network CPM. Choose which is more important to you.

Use heatmaps and eye-tracking research
Here is Google’s eye-tracking heat map of where readers engage with ads on a webpage. Look for other eye-tracking research online and use the findings to guide your page design decisions. Ask other publishers what has worked for them. (FWIW, I’ve had huge success with a medium rectangle placed at the top of a 300-pixel-wide right-side navigation bar.)

Then experiment, using A/B testing wherever you can to find the simple, elegant page design and ad position that delivers the highest CPM for you.

Know SEO
Writing in a style that’s optimized for search engines should be reflex for anyone writing online. Know the search terms that would-be readers are likely to use when searching for an article such as yours and use those terms in your headline, your lead and throughout the story. Don’t publish duplicates of the same story at multiple URLs.

SEO is important not only in driving readers to your website, it’s essential in helping AdSense know what would be the most appropriate ads to serve on a specific page on a particular website. Lots of promos to other, semi-related content elsewhere on your site confuses the search engines, often leading to poorly-targeted ads. Lose those promos and simplify both your writing and page design to elicit better-targeted ads.

Don’t compete with yourself
Many websites are designed in an attempt to get readers to click to other content on that site, once they’ve finished on a specific page. Ads are placed as afterthoughts within that design.

I say, when readers have a choice between clicking on another page on my site or an ad, I’d rather they click on the ad. Why? Because that click makes me money right now. And if a reader is really interested in content on my site, well, he or she found me before, and they can find me again.

Create sharply focused evergreen topic pages
This is where news websites fail. AdSense delivers its best results on pages that have been around long enough for Google to collect some data about what ads work on that page, and what ads don’t. News sites, with an ever-changing line-up of flash-in-the-pan articles, elicit poorly targeted ads because those articles don’t stick around long enough to build any history with AdSense.

And when individual pages don’t build any history, neither does the website.

Web publishers need a foundation of core URLs, sharply targeted to individual topics, that will continue to attract traffic over long periods of time. Envision an SEO-focused, “Wikipedia”-style guide to your beat, but written (or at least controlled) by your staff. That’s what you need, both to establish a strong base of AdSense income and to direct Google in selecting and displaying relevant AdSense ads everywhere else on your website.

In conclusion, you want:

The right ad formats,

in a simple design,

around sharply focused writing,

on a core of evergreen content pages.

Stop treating AdSense as an afterthought, or a no-thought-at-all, and you’ll begin to see better results.

Are You Okay, Web?

Believe me or not, but there’s something seriously wrong with the web. In fact, I have observed that it has never recovered after the May 14 trauma that it experienced when Google systems went out of order.

During the past 10 days or so, most of the sites are showing totally erratic behavior. They’re either not opening up or only some pages are working for them. When you click on the links, they refuse to work. Or text appears but pictures disappear. And after sometime, everything is suddenly normal. No, it’s not any evil spirit. I don’t believe in that. Then?

First, I thought the interruptions are happening to high-traffic content sites. But no; it’s true even for one-visitor-a-day kind of company sites also. As I couldn’t find any pattern in this change, it seems to be all random. This could be a local problem also in my area (I live in New Delhi, India and use a Wi-Fi connection for Internet access.)

If other users are also facing such a problem, they may use the “Comments” section with this article to share their experiences.

This may be a local or temporary flaw. In general, however, I must tell you that this web thing is not yet stable. I have been using various web tools and technologies for over 10 years and have written a lot about them. During this period, I’ve observed that their number has been increasing exponentially, but their reliability has always ebbed down. Most of the web technologies – from search to social sites to analytics to content systems – are too raw and shaky.

And now this “social” trend is adding fuel to the fire. Today, any company that has anything to do with the web is hugely infatuated with this social thing. In the process, these companies are encouraging users to throw everything brought from everywhere into their own or public social sites.

So there’s an unruly hoo-hah in and around social media or social networking sites. While that has resulted in the creation of some colossal “information junkyards,” there are millions of people all over the world who want to be part of this mad social scramble. Obviously, when this crowd is growing, web is going to wilt under the pressure.

This could be a reason that after sometime web needs rest these days, and it’s slow in responding actively to users’ requests. Do you agree?

Rakesh Raman is the managing editor of My Techbox Online.
This article was published on May 25, 2009 at http://www.mytechboxonline.com/mtoweb/web-rrweb-05.html
You may please see the original version that also has reference links.